Well, I survived my first
actual Nine Inch Nails concert. And my second. In the same weekend.
My friend
Beavette kindly wrangled an extra ticket for me on two of the three nights of the Midwest leg of their "small cities" tour (Champaign, Milwaukee, Moline). Lots of driving, lots of "Head Like a Hole", and last night, lots of very aggro moshing. He's got a whole new generation of frat-boy fans, one of whom was dropped on my head. Yeah, we were about 8 feet from the rail -- probably the most intense concert I've ever been to...
I'm not a new fan -- I got into them because of
Doom, and owned
The Downward Spiral and
Broken, but didn't go see them or follow the Halo releases closely (and they still ended up at the top of my Last.FM stats -- go figure). But I loved the new album a lot, and had just been soaking up the tour experience vicariously, as Beavette has bounced around the country hitting many of the shows. These were right in town, though, and priced a little nicer than when they were in Chicago, so it all worked out very nicely for me to be involved.
The opening band (
Moving Units) is a kind of harder-edged Bravery/Interpol outfit. They seemed scared on night 2, with the lead singer actually dressed in a winter coat, almost as a suit of armor; but night 3 they cut loose and had more fun and did a better job pumping up the audience.
Reznor was pretty cool. Tight road band, didn't do much talking, great coverage of his material. The band used video footage projected on a scrim in front of the band to really good effect during some songs, making a lot of them more explicitly political, like "Eraser" (from 1994's
The Downward Spiral) and "Hand that Feeds" (which is the one from
With Teeth that MTV refused to let him play with a Bush photo as backdrop), as well as "Right Where It Belongs". It's still unclear to me whether any of these songs were written with political meanings at the forefront -- they're certainly abstract enough that they can apply much more broadly. (I'm not suggesting that he get topical, though -- that's a lot more difficult to do well.) At any rate, his audience certainly didn't seem to object to the politics -- there were quite a few middle fingers raised when Bush came on screen 20 feet high.
In Wisconsin, continuing the political theme, he took a moment out to excoriate -- as a former resident of New Orleans -- the 11 Congressmen who voted against the $50B Katrina relief bill last fall, one of whom (Sensenbrenner) represents the very Red suburbs of Milwaukee. Though the crowd enthusiastically agreed with Reznor, it's unlikely to have much political effect; last re-election he got 64%. In Moline he ripped into the music industry and said some nice words about the live crowd reminding him of why he does this.
Milwaukee, partly because of the venue -- an enormous ballroom, probably a former union hall of some sort, which made it very difficult to stage a show with anything like an arena sound or ambience -- the main crowd hazard was cigarette smoke and spilled beer. (I love the fact that these older buildings are still being used, but even though I completely understand why it's done, I wish they wouldn't paint everything black and have everything look unmaintained and ghetto when the lights are on.) There were a few fun freaks, including a miniskirted suicide-girl type wearing a "suggestion box" on her back. They couldn't do the scrims here, either, so the setlist was quite different -- I'm pretty sure they only played four songs from the new album, but they did hit Reznor's top all-time songs like "Something I Can Never Have", "Closer" and "Hurt".
Moline was in many ways a better show. Beavette and I hiked it out across the prairie beginning in mid-afternoon, but still got there in time (despite some navigational glitches attributable to Google Maps -- Double True) to stake out places on the main floor in what's basically a minor-league hockey arena. The not-especially-diminutive Beavette was determined this show to get up close enough to really see Reznor, and not get trapped behind one of the numerous obstacles known as "guys of normal height". Here's where my admitted bulk actually provides an advantage in life, for once. When the crush toward the front and the moshing began I took my job to be doing as much blocking and defense of position as possible. Beavette worried about a real crush -- she's been in a few -- but it never got that bad; there were a few mass waves that nearly knocked even me off my feet a few times (and here it was clearly a case of the bigger they come). Considering the longevity of Reznor's career it was interesting just how many frat boys with twenty years on me there were. There was a dough-faced cornfed guy who actually had almost a whole head's height on
me, and a certain obliviousness that being that large and unmovable must contribute toward; I nicknamed him "
Lenny", but ultimately Beavette was able to get him to stay out of her way just by tapping him on the shoulder and asking nicely. That's the Midwest for ya. (For my part, I actually ducked down to pick up somebody else's
hat once.) There was a lot of crowd-surfing, too, but at least this venue treated it as a misdemeanor -- the guards were giving people soft landings in front of the stage and letting them circle around and re-enter. There were some punk, goth, and cosplay freaks here, too.
Here's where my head got hurt. I was keeping an eye on the overhead activity -- being off to the side most people were going right up the center past us. But behind us there was a slam-dancing hole of sorts and somebody must have come up from there and either did a running jump or just wasn't being conveyor-belted by the community properly, because the first warning I had was his torso slamming down on top of my skull,
bam. It wasn't something that left a bruise on my head, but more of a soreness at the back of my neck. The worst that had happened to me in Milwaukee was some sloshed beer in my hair (and down Beavette's pants...). We did see a guy, as we left, who had a big 2-3" gash on his forehead (but he was too drunk to be feeling it).
The sound in the arena was much better than the ballroom, so that was a huge plus. (I had a touch of ringing in one ear after Milwaukee, but I think that was mainly positioning. At any case, though I'll never catch up with the aggregate concert decibels of Beavette or her friend G., I really should start wearing earplugs.)
The pre-show music was kinda interesting all by itself -- dance-punky tracks personally selected by Reznor, including a few favorites of my own, like Talk Talk's "Such a Shame". My own personal geeky take on this was to tag them all on Last.FM [using a list from echoingthesound.org] as "
nin preshow music" (and about 80% of them are streamable).
Reznor hadn't been very athletic in Milwaukee, but that was just the small stage. His new clean & sober outlook has him (I'd guess) substituting working out for other recreations, so he's incredibly ripped, and here he bounced around a lot, even though he doesn't get into the crowd-surfing himself like he used to at old shows and other craziness (he leaves a lot of that to guitarist Aaron North, who frequently destroys guitars and tosses them to the audience). Oh, he also switched from a leather vest in Milwaukee to a kind of silk dress shirt in Moline -- with the sweat and the pleather pants it gives him a kind of rained-on businessman look. He's old enough and has been through the rock star wringer enough to be able to just wear what he wants, and that's cool in its own way. He seems to be big on the tambourine this tour, using it about a half-dozen times over the two nights.
The tour drummer Josh Freese, a last-minute replacement due to a falling out with his old drummer, is turning out to be a great choice and hopefully he'll be available to play with the band a lot in the future -- but he's already one of the most in-demand session drummers in the industry, so who knows if that will work out. I can't compare with other shows, of course, but it was my impression that the band was playing very tight and the drummer is always a critical gear in the machine. The keyboardist Alessandro Cortini and bassist Jeordie "Twiggy
Rodriguez Ramirez" White were also excellent and very much contributing members.
Again, I'm no NIN connoisseur, but between the two nights almost all my favorite tracks were played and I wasn't disappointed once. Even the multi-layered "Closer" and other TDS material came off pretty well for a stage re-creation. There was definitely one track that I think I like more for having seen live, "Getting Smaller" (even though I already like it because it has what I consider the absolute quintessential Trent lyric: "I've still got my one good arm, that I can, I can beat, I can beat
myself up with" ...) It was songs like this that really brought out the pogo dancing and intensity -- definite crowd-pleasers. I was trying hard to stay a little more subdued during "Only" because Beavette had expressed some distaste for frat-boys dancing to a song that she considers a kind of emotional skinning, but it was really hard to resist just bumping along. That may be a pure guy thing, there. But I'd like to see a stripped-down acoustic version, like he's done of some other songs. My big failing is not knowing the whole lyrics for songs that aren't in my top few favorites, let alone being able to identify them before they really get started, but that's why having Beavette along was a big boon -- she was always able to identify them from even the most tenuous of introductory phrasings.
To keep this from getting any longer, I'll just say that this has definitely been the highlight of my year so far. Beavette hinted at a Ministry concert later this year, and all I could say was "Hmmm."